Poll: Vote for the best
This poll is closed.
Shorogan
10.96%
8 10.96%
Xidd
38.36%
28 38.36%
Reaper
20.55%
15 20.55%
Blue Phoenix/Phil/Eddie
30.14%
22 30.14%
Total 73 vote(s) 100%
* You voted for this item. [Show Results]

Thread Rating:
  • 0 Vote(s) - 0 Average
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Contest #12 - EXE Skinning Competition - VOTING
#11
actually i expected much more from any of the entries.

take shorogan. the color theme is awesome, so is the new soundtrack. but the ads dont fit into it at all, and you cant even download it.
and to xidd: well, great graphics and wheel system (and you removed the ads :D), but not even half of the work done.
to reaper: well, its nice, but the ads again dont fit into it at all, plus its nothing really special, nothing that made me go "woot!".
to bp, eddie and phil: luv the drawings and the lifebars. and maybe the buttons. but the rest is just worse than the original.

in the end i decided to vote for shorogan (mainly cause of the soundtrack) and the teamwork (cause the drawings simply amazed me).

dont flame me for this hard critique :P

The Lost Global Mod edited this post 08-31-2010 03:55 PM because:
u mentioned the buttons (which were made by me) so i am not flaming :p
Thanks given by:
#12
I shall have to download them to give a proper vote :P
you don't want to see this (Click to View)
avatar by Una
the other by xFire
Thanks given by:
#13
I totally agree with nave on this one. Not that I don't like you guys overall, but the bg is not so superior.

Thus, voted for Xidd :p
Thanks given by:
#14
Quote-spree incoming...

(08-31-2010, 05:33 AM)Alectric Wrote:  oh wow, i completely forgot about this contest :S
too busy...
anyway, Blue Phoenix, Phil, & eddie, and Xidd got my vote.
I believe, you're not the only one. Fairly disappointing, really. Also, thanks for the vote.

(08-31-2010, 01:01 PM)TheNave Wrote:  nah srsly, what's so great about that teamwork project, imo it's just rushed and bad...
I agree about the rushed part, "bad" might be a little harsh according to my dictionary. Anyways, points taken, next team-work will follow a little different lines.

(08-31-2010, 01:01 PM)TheNave Wrote:  btw. voted for Xidd 'cuz [...] everything harmonies with eachother...
*cough* other menus *cough*

(08-31-2010, 03:18 PM)Bamboori Wrote:  actually i expected much more from any of the entries.
Too bad that there was no competition whatsoever.

(08-31-2010, 03:18 PM)Bamboori Wrote:  take shorogan. [...] the ads dont fit into it at all, and you cant even download it
This is not related to changing the exe. You would have to edit the ad-files to have it ad-less. Also, I sent him a PM to give me the download-link ASAP.
@Alblaka: can you force him to do that? :p

(08-31-2010, 03:18 PM)Bamboori Wrote:  to xidd: [...] (and you removed the ads :D)
I'd recommend you download the exe and reassess that statement.

(08-31-2010, 03:18 PM)Bamboori Wrote:  to reaper: well, its nice, but the ads again dont fit into it at all, plus its nothing really special, nothing that made me go "woot!".
Well, we know about the ads now. I actually like that he's the only one that dared to mess with lee on road & created a connection between main-menu and the bg itself. Simple, yet effective.

(08-31-2010, 03:18 PM)Bamboori Wrote:  to bp, eddie and phil: luv the drawings and the lifebars. and maybe the buttons. but the rest is just worse than the original.
I guess this is a matter of personal taste. Not wanting to argue with you about that as it could easily be understood in a misleading way.

(08-31-2010, 03:18 PM)Bamboori Wrote:  dont flame me for this hard critique :P
No flaming intended, and I do respect your opinions. Thanks for the vote, by the way!

All for now.
Silverthorn
~ Breaking LFE since 2008 ~


» Gallery | » Sprites | » devArt
Thanks given by: Bamboori
#15
Xidd has my vote on this. The EXE has somewhat creativity and it also had Hex. It may be unfinished, but it looks like it could of had some interesting images.
the others are also very good.
"'~Nirvana Is Salvation Of Your Soul~'"
[Image: yurisignn.jpg]
[Image: yurisig2.jpg]
Thanks given by:
#16
(09-01-2010, 12:58 AM)Blue Phoenix Wrote:  
(08-31-2010, 01:01 PM)TheNave Wrote:  btw. voted for Xidd 'cuz [...] everything harmonies with eachother...
*cough* other menus *cough*

I meant all the finished stuff ofc...
Thanks given by:
#17
A little feedback from my side - don't read everything I say as applicable for everyone, I am a little weird and have a weird taste :P

Shorogan - Nice to see a little overhaul, but in overall, the green would burn my eyes after playing for a little while.

Xidd - Even if there was hex in this one and it was well done; just not appealing. I mean, plain white screen with a little fancy text and... lips?! What does that have to do with LF2?!

Raper - In overall I liked this entry best. Can't explain exactly why, but I guess everything just fits in very well.

BlPhEd - Colors appealing to the eye, nice drawings, however you could have at least fixed those s sprites. And at Phil, before you flame me: I don't see any buttons :P

v: Then please update your screenshots. Oh and those buttons, they are different from the original? Don't they change with the color scheme?

edit again: Oh I see now. Text color clashes too much with the upper button background color. :P

The Lost Global Mod edited this post 09-01-2010 11:03 AM because:
i can flame you even more.. s sprites are fixed! and check your eyes if you don't see the buttons. look at recording, network etc.
Quote of the Day f***ing Year (Click to View)
The meme is real (Click to View)
Thanks given by:
#18
my-Efficient Blood Pressure Pin
E=eddie
BP=_-_-_
P=phill:D
nobody likes me:'(:'(:'(:'(
Thanks given by:
#19
I don't know how to do any of this stuff, so this is a massive congrats to
everyone who entered, they all look pretty sweet. :D

I like a lot of stuff in Shorogan's, like a lot of the text, the loading display,
the little symbols, and the use of the green isn't overly flamboyant for the
most part. :)

Xidd's is pretty damn sleek, it's a shame he didn't finish more.

I like a fair bit of Reaper's, it's very toned, pleasant to look at, and as a side
note the red full moon of the vs-mode is awesome.

BP, Phil, and Eddie's is pretty sweet too, almost all of the massive face-pics
are awesome, the health and magic bars are sweet, and it's generally easy
on the eyes.

Shorogan and Reaper get my vote.

Edit: Heh, tied vote b/w Xidd and BP/Phil/Eddie. :p
Trust you're all well.
Thanks given by:
#20
Xidd got my vote he created new cool menus! only need the others parts of the game...
<a href="http://www.danasoft.com"><img src="http://www.danasoft.com/sig/331930271607.jpg" border="0"></a><div style="font-family:arial,sans-serif;font-size:11px;"><p>Sign by Danasoft - <a href="http://www.danasoft.com">For Backgrounds and Layouts</a></p></div> I am from Brazil [Image: imagem3ku.jpg] Brazil in LFE! :D world cup soccer:Brazil 999x -1 Others
my current work (Click to View)
now with enabled PM!
Thanks given by:




Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)